Masculinity and the Unintentional Mind

June 1, 2023

To Think

To understand masculinity from a traditional perspective, we turn to the teachings of philosophers who revered virtue as the cornerstone of noble character. For them, masculinity was not merely a biological marker or a societal construct but a manifestation of virtues that transcended time and cultural contexts.

Aristotle, the venerable Greek philosopher, posited that masculinity finds its expression through the cultivation of virtues. According to him, the virtuous man exemplifies the Golden Mean, balancing courage with prudence, strength with temperance, and assertiveness with magnanimity. In Aristotle's view, masculinity is characterized by a harmonious integration of noble virtues that enable men to navigate the complexities of life with wisdom and integrity.

“In Aristotle's view, masculinity is characterized by a harmonious integration of noble virtues that enable men to navigate the complexities of life with wisdom and integrity.”

Drawing inspiration from ancient Roman stoicism, the ideal of the virtuous warrior emerges. Stoic philosophers like Seneca celebrated masculinity rooted in self-discipline, resilience, and honor. They believed that true strength lay not in dominance or aggression but in the disciplined control of one's emotions, adherence to duty, and commitment to justice.

Throughout history, traditional philosophers recognized the role of men as protectors and providers for their families and communities. From the teachings of Aquinas to the writings of Rousseau, the notion of masculinity as a responsible and dependable force emerged. This traditional perspective acknowledges the importance of male strength and assertiveness in safeguarding and sustaining the well-being of others.

Islamic scholars, such as Imam Ghazali and Ibn Sina, emphasized the cultivation of intellect and wisdom as essential aspects of masculinity. They believed that true masculinity lies in the pursuit of knowledge, critical thinking, and intellectual growth. By seeking knowledge, men develop the capacity to navigate life's challenges, contribute to society, and fulfill their role as stewards of the Earth.

Throughout Islamic history, chivalry and honor have been central to the ideal of masculinity. Influenced by the concept of futuwwa, or chivalry, exemplified by the knights of old, Islamic traditions encourage men to exhibit courage, generosity, and ethical conduct. This notion of masculinity emphasizes the protection of the weak, defense of justice, and the fulfillment of one's responsibilities as a guardian of society.

Intentionality as the Cornerstone

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was recorded as saying, "Verily, actions are by intentions, and for every person is what he intended ". Across time, ancient philosophers celebrated the cultivation of virtue, emphasizing the significance of intentional actions. By consciously choosing to embody noble virtues like courage, temperance, and justice, men shape their character and contribute to the betterment of themselves and society. Intentionality becomes their compass, guiding them towards a purpose-driven and meaningful existence.

Islamic teachings further illuminate the importance of intentionality. Through intention (niyyah), men align their actions with the teachings of Islam, seeking to please Allah and fulfill their spiritual obligations. By cultivating mindfulness, sincerity, and devotion, they infuse intentionality into all aspects of life. This conscious direction of intention fuels their masculinity with purpose and divine guidance.

“By reflecting upon their true selves and aligning their actions with core values, men navigate the complexities of modern life with integrity. ”

Cultural norms provide a framework for intentionality to find expression in masculinity. Men are called to be intentional in their roles as providers, protectors, and leaders within their families and communities. By consciously engaging with their responsibilities, making deliberate choices, and embodying traditional values, men shape their masculine identity with honor, loyalty, and dedication. Their intentional pursuit of these values inspires others and fosters a sense of purpose in collective endeavors.

Intentionality in masculinity allows men to unveil their authenticity. By reflecting upon their true selves and aligning their actions with core values, men navigate the complexities of modern life with integrity. Embracing their unique strengths, vulnerabilities, and passions, they transcend societal expectations, forging a path that resonates with their authentic selves. This intentional self-discovery cultivates a masculinity that is genuine, empowering, and attuned to their own being.

As men embrace intentionality, their actions send ripples through the fabric of society. Each intentional choice, whether in pursuit of virtue, spiritual growth, or the well-being of others, inspires positive change in families, communities, and beyond. The power of intentionality lies not only in personal transformation but also in its capacity to shape a collective consciousness that honors integrity, empathy, and purpose.

In the tapestry of masculinity, intentionality becomes a transformative force, redefining the modern narrative. Through the wisdom of ancient philosophers, Islamic teachings, and cultural norms, men rediscover the power of conscious choice and deliberate action. By embracing intentionality, they elevate their masculinity beyond societal expectations, infusing it with purpose, authenticity, and positive impact. As men navigate the complexities of the modern world, let them remember that intentionality guides them towards the true essence of masculinity, empowering them to shape a better future through conscious and purposeful living.

Unintentionality and the Degradation of the Soul

The three-letter root "gha-fa-la" (غ-ف-ل) in Arabic refers to heedlessness, negligence, or being unaware. It denotes a state of being spiritually or mentally absent, disconnected, or neglectful of important matters.

Intentionality, intertwined with consciousness, is the catalyst that propels men towards progress and transformation. It is the deliberate choice to align thoughts, choices, and actions with one's values, purpose, and aspirations. By embodying intentionality, men navigate life with a sense of direction and purpose. They become active participants in their own journey, taking responsibility for their growth and shaping their masculinity in a meaningful and authentic way.

Within the realm of mindfulness, the analysis of one's value hierarchy takes on great significance. Men begin to question the motivations and intentions behind their actions, unraveling the layers of conditioning and societal influences that shape their choices. They ask themselves why they automatically reach for that cup of coffee upon waking, why they choose specific clothing, or how they react to various scenarios. By analyzing their value hierarchy, men gain insight into their true desires, aspirations, and authentic selves, enabling them to make choices aligned with their deepest values.

“The focus on self-expression and individualism can overshadow the cultivation of virtues”

When mindfulness is absent, men become inherently susceptible to external influences that permeate their lives. Society bombards them with relentless messages, societal norms, and cultural expectations that may not align with their authentic selves. The lack of mindfulness renders them vulnerable to manipulation and conformity.

When men lack mindfulness, society suffers from a collective state of disconnection and unawareness. Mindlessness perpetuates apathy, indifference, and a lack of empathy towards others. It hinders the ability to truly understand and address societal issues, leading to a fragmented and disjointed community. Without mindfulness, men may fail to recognize the broader consequences of their actions, further exacerbating social problems and perpetuating harmful cycles.

While traditional philosophy offers this wisdom, the post-modern paradigm has veered toward a critical redefinition of masculinity, often with unintended consequences. The rejection of traditional gender roles and the deconstruction of established norms have blurred the lines of masculinity, leaving many men grappling with uncertainty and a loss of identity.

In the post-modern perspective, masculinity is sometimes reduced to a mere performance, detached from any moral or ethical foundation. The focus on self-expression and individualism can overshadow the cultivation of virtues, resulting in a fragmented sense of identity and a lack of guidance in navigating life's challenges.

Post-modernism's emphasis on the subjective nature of truth and the rejection of universal values has eroded the sense of purpose and moral compass that traditional masculinity once provided. Without a shared understanding of virtue, men can find themselves adrift in a sea of relativism, devoid of a solid foundation upon which to anchor their actions and aspirations. As a result, they become lost and lead other astray.

The very nature of a man is to lead - whether he accepts the role or not, he will be followed in some form or fashion.